When I am assessing someone with Lymphoedema, heart failure is an important consideration I want to rule out, especially if the clients presents with bilateral leg swelling. Why I want to rule out heart failure, is because heart failure can be a partial or absolute coointroindications to compression garments, bandaging and manual lymphatic drainage (MLD). However, when the heart cannot manage the circulating blood volume effectively, moving additional fluid from the legs back towards the circulation may increase the workload on the heart. As a Clinical Myotherapist and trained lymphoedema therapist at Melbourne Massage and Treatment Myotherapy and Lymphoedema Clinic in Coburg, I consider a person’s medical history, cardiovascular stability and the likely cause of their swelling before recommending lymphoedema treatment. In this article, I explain what heart failure is, how compression therapy may help at different levels of heart failure, when compression should be avoided, why MLD is contraindicated in decompensated heart failure, and how eligible Victorian residents may apply for subsidised compression garments through SWEP. What Is Heart Failure? Heart failure, as the name suggests, is a medical condition characterised by the difficulties of the heart in pumping blood effectively to meet the body’s needs. This doesn’t mean that the heart has stopped or will stop working, but it means that its pumping function, filling function or both are impaired. There are different types of heart failure: Heart failure with reduced ejection fraction (HFrEF): The heart’s left ventricle has reduced pumping capacity. Heart failure with preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF): The heart’s left ventricle has difficulty relaxing or filling properly, despite a relatively preserved ejection fraction. Right-sided heart failure: The right side of the heart struggles to pump blood towards the lungs, potentially contributing to fluid accumulation in the legs and abdomen. Left-sided heart failure: The left side of the heart struggles to pump blood into the systemic circulation. Pressure may build up in the pulmonary circulation, potentially causing breathlessness and fluid accumulation in the lungs. More than one of those presentations can coexist at the same time. Why can heart failure cause swelling in the legs? While the heart is unable to manage blood circulation, the excess fluid that doesn’t get moved can sit in the system and accumulate. This can also lead to the kidneys retaining sodium and water in response to changes in circulation. These processes can contribute to fluid moving from the blood vessels into the surrounding tissues, producing peripheral oedema. Common symptoms and signs of heart failure include: Swelling around the ankles, feet and lower legs. Shortness of breath during physical activity or at rest. Difficulty breathing when lying flat. Waking at night feeling short of breath. Unusual fatigue and reduced exercise tolerance. Rapid weight gain associated with fluid retention. Leg swelling is not enough to diagnose heart failure, and I am not in any position to be able to diagnose anyone with heart failure. That said, when someone presents with oedema in their legs, I just want to make sure to rule out heart failure as a cause of the swelling, and if needed, I may refer my client back to the GP for further investigation. On the other hand, chronic venous insufficiency, kidney disease, medication effects and other conditions can also cause oedema. A medical assessment is important to identify the underlying cause. While you read this blog, if you are experiencing rapidly worsening breathlessness, chest pain, fainting, or severe breathing difficulty, you require urgent medical assessment. Call 000 for severe or life-threatening symptoms. Understanding the Severity of Heart Failure The New York Heart Association (NYHA) functional classification is commonly used to describe how heart failure affects a person’s physical activity and symptoms. NYHA class Functional limitation Implications for compression Class I No limitation of ordinary physical activity due to heart failure symptoms. Compression may be appropriate if heart failure is stable and other contraindications have been excluded. Class II Mild limitation. Ordinary activity may cause fatigue, palpitations or breathlessness. Compression may be appropriate when clinically stable, usually starting cautiously with lower-leg compression. Class III Marked limitation. Less-than-ordinary activity causes symptoms. Avoid routine compression without specialist assessment. Consider only for a clear indication with appropriate clinical monitoring. Class IV Symptoms may occur at rest, and physical activity causes increased discomfort. Compression is generally contraindicated, particularly in severe or decompensated heart failure. Specialist management is required. Those classes are based on functional symptoms rather than the heart’s ejection fraction and they do not replace a clinical assessment. What you should also be aware of is that heart failure can change over time, passing from one class to another. When passing from class II to class III, as per the example, compression should be re-evaluated and maybe discontinued. Again, at Melbourne Massage and Treatment, I am not in any position to confirm or recommend compression for heart failure symptom management. This has to be done together with your GP and cardiologist’s assessment and decision-making. How Can Compression Therapy Help? What compression therapy has to offer is external pressure to support fluid movement from the tissues towards the lymphatic and venous systems. Based on the severity of the presentation, treatment may involve graduated compression stockings, adjustable compression wraps or multilayer bandaging. These options are not interchangeable, and the choice should reflect the person’s vascular status, skin condition, limb shape, mobility and ability to apply the garment safely. In people with stable heart failure, compression may help manage coexisting venous or lymphatic oedema, but is not a treatment for heart failure itself. It is only for oedema management. 1. Stable heart failure: NYHA Class I When heart failure is stable and there are no significant symptoms during ordinary activity, compression may be considered for a confirmed indication such as venous insufficiency or lymphoedema. Before recommending compression, I would consider: Whether the swelling has been medically investigated. Whether the heart failure is stable and adequately managed. Whether peripheral arterial circulation is sufficient for compression. Whether there are any skin problems, sensory deficits or other contraindications. Whether the […]
Monthly Archives: October 2026
In my experience as a Clinical Myotherapist at Melbourne Massage and Treatment Myotherapy and Lymphoedema Clinic in Coburg, I often look beyond the area where a person feels pain. Sometimes, the problem is not simply a tight muscle or a local injury. The way a muscle contracts, controls movement or produces force can also tell us something about how the nervous system is working. To better understand this, let’s use an example: unilateral hamstring weakness, where one hamstring appears weaker than the other. This can become particularly important when someone continues training, lifting weights or performing exercises that require both sides of the body to work together, like a squat. There are several possible explanations for this presentation. One of them involves the lumbar spine, including irritation of the facet joints and, in some cases, changes that affect the nearby nerve roots. The important point is that you do not always need to experience numbness, tingling or the typical symptoms of neuropathy to have a problem with muscular control that deserves further assessment. What are the facet joint? The facet joints, also known as zygapophyseal joints, are small synovial joints located in the posterior portion of the spine on each side of the vertebrae, and they help guide and control spinal movement. Facet joints’ role is to contribute to each spinal segment’s stability, together with the intervertebral disc. Therefore, they help manage loads during movements such as bending backwards, rotating the trunk and returning to an upright position. As with any joints, even facet joints can become irritated if placed under excessive loading, repetitive movements, trauma or degenerative changes that develop over time. Indeed, anyone, in their lifetime, would experience some form of facet joint degeneration. When a facet joint becomes painful, symptoms may include localised lower back pain, stiffness and pain that refers into the buttock or thigh (Meralgia parestetica). That said, not everyone with facet joint irritation experiences the same symptoms, and degenerative changes on an X-ray or MRI do not automatically mean those changes cause the person’s pain. Indeed, as we already discussed in other blogs, pain is brain interpratiation of a stressor fact, not only a and not always a response to a “damaged” body tissue. That’s where, looking at research on facet joint disorders, we can see the importance of combining the clinical presentation with an appropriate physical examination rather than relying on imaging findings alone. Can facet joint irritation affect a nerve? The quick answer to the above question is: Yes, it can. But there is a catch too. Indeed, a facet joint irritation can manifest itself and refer pain to areas of the body that are far from the facet joint itself, but still not irritating a nerve or a nerve’s root. So in the first instance, the irritated facet joint produces pain. Therefore, surrounding muscles may become more sensitive, guarded or less effective at producing movement because of pain. On the other hand, structural changes around the facet joint may reduce the space available for a nearby spinal nerve root, leading to still pain, but also to a lack of motor control and ability to use a muscle. And again, to identify what is what, we need to go through a tailored assessment, and only via this approach can we get a better clinical understanding of what the root cause of your pain is. And what is most important to keep in mind is that not everyone experiences all these symptoms together. Can nerve involvement occur without numbness or tingling? As briefly explained before, when someone experiences facet joint irritation, as part of their symptoms, they may experience loss of control of a specific muscle or group of muscles. That said, the loss of motor control is not always related to numbness, tingling or burning pain. So a spinal nerve root contains fibres involved in both sensory and motor functions, and based on the location and severity of the problem, these functions may not be affected equally. Together with active, passive and resisted range of motion, we can then start narrowing down the clinical presentation and any potential facet joint irritation and/or involvement of a nerve compression. Why does unilateral muscle weakness matter? If someone presents with unilateral muscle weakness, which can happen when there is inflammation at the facet joint along the spine, you may end up compensating during everyday movement or at the gym with the functional side to deliver an action. Let’s make an example by looking at a hamstring that is not firing, due to nerve impingement via an irritated facet joint. Let’s take the case of a client who presents at the clinic with a right hamstring group, the muscle in the back of the thigh, which is not firing. While this person does walk, squat, or does a double-leg hamstring curl, they may notice the impairment. And this is a common presentation when the weakness, given by a non-firing muscle, is not correlated to any form of pain, at least in the targeted muscle. What happens if you continue training with one weak hamstring? Now the concern is not that every strength difference will inevitably cause an injury. We know that one side is more efficient at delivering power than the other side; that’s because we are either right- or left-dominant. The concern arises when a meaningful weakness changes the way someone performs an exercise. Depending on the movement, this could involve shifting more weight onto the stronger leg, rotating the pelvis or trunk, changing the depth of the movement or modifying how the hips and knees contribute to the lift. The other side may consequently perform more work than intended. The weaker side may also be exposed to loads it cannot currently manage well. This is to say that having one side not firing or working as well as it should can lead to injury, but it also can lead to waste of training, as a muscle that can’t perform at its full potential, due […]
Pain is something that we all experience, and it can start after an injury, during an illness, following surgery, or even without an obvious cause. Indeed, pain is not always related to body damage, like a muscle tear or a broken bone. In support of this, to better understand pain, modern science shows us that pain is a complex experience produced by the nervous system. It is influenced by information coming from the body, but also by previous experiences, expectations, emotions, stress, sleep and the context in which the pain occurs. The International Association for the Study of Pain (IASP) defines pain as an unpleasant sensory and emotional experience associated with, or resembling that associated with, actual or potential tissue damage. What we have to understand, to start with, is that pain can occur even when there is little or no ongoing tissue damage. That’s really important when we talk about chronic pain. What is chronic pain? By definition, chronic pain is described as pain that persists or recurs for more than three months. That said, this doesn’t mean that an injury has remained damaged for such a long time. In fact, in some people, pain initially begins because of an injury or another physical problem but continues after the original tissue has had enough time to heal. This is where chronic pain can develop, because the nervous system has become more sensitive to signals from the body. So yes, even after such a long time and with physical damage repaired, the nervous system is still in alert mode, creating a signal of pain, where actually nothing physical npothing is wrong. This is one reason why treating chronic pain is often more complicated than simply finding a damaged muscle, tendon or joint and treating that structure. Chronic pain can involve different mechanisms, including nociceptive, neuropathic and nociplastic pain, and more than one mechanism can be present at the same time. Pain does not always equal damage When I treat patients who suffer from chronic pain, including pain that recurs after years, I have to ensure I explain how pain actually works, and that pain and tissue damage are not always directly proportional. Indeed, we are all aware that we all have different pain tolerance, and that someone can have significant pain with relatively little tissue damage, while another person can have substantial structural changes with surprisingly little pain. This does not mean that the pain is imaginary, or that you have to feel crazy to be in constant pain. Unfortunately, the pain is real. But what this means is that we need to create a management program to change how your nervous system is dealing with pain management and response. Because at the base of it all is that when pain persists for a long time, the sensitivity of the pain system can change. This can contribute to increased sensitivity to pressure, movement or other normally tolerable stimuli. It is like an alarm that went on every day for weeks, and then months, and out of nowhere, any stimulus can trigger it. So yes, this is one of the reasons why chronic pain needs to be approached as more than a local problem in a muscle or joint. Why can pain continue after an injury has healed? After an initial injury, or a nociceptive stimulus, pain can hang around even when no stimulus of major level is left. A stimulus that could give you pain is getting spiked with a needle, for example, when doing a blood test. If that same experience is then associated with a major stressor, like a trauma- think of pain that started after a severe car accident- the pain can be more challenging, because your central nervous system is now associating the pain not only with a physical injury (a needle penetrating the skin) but to a severe car accident. That trauma, that intense experience, can now wire your nervous system to be in alert mode constantly and therefore constantly fire a pain response, even though the physical damage is repaired. Other factors can also influence pain processing, including: Higher level of stress Poor sleep Previous pain experiences Fear of movement Expectations about what a particular movement might do to the body. So yes, you now can also understand that avoiding movement completely is not always the best long-term solution, because that fear of movement can increase the pain expectation and experience. Can hands-on treatment help chronic pain? This is another topic I find myself sharing constantly with my clients. Hands-on treatment, yes, is extremely helpful with chronic pain, and here is why. Manual therapy, that is, Remedial Massage or MLD, can provide a strong sensory input to the nervous system. Any form of touch therapy, indeed, is simply a stimulation to the nervous system. The trust built with my clients and the nervous system touch stimulation create a positive cycle that can help modulate the pain response for the better. In more detail, touch, pressure and movement stimulate sensory receptors and provide the brain with new information about the area being treated. This can influence how pain is processed and may temporarily reduce pain sensitivity. A systematic review and meta-analysis of physical therapy interventions in people with chronic musculoskeletal pain found improvements in some measures associated with pain processing, including temporal summation and conditioned pain modulation. The authors concluded that physical therapy may have a modest effect on altered pain processing, although the results differed between treatment approaches. But even if science backed up the benefit of hands-on treatment for chronic pain, we have to remember that massage can only provide pain modulation, and no one, with their hands, can actually fix a problem or heal you. And I can stress this enough to my clients. In fact, I always explain to them that I see hands-on treatment as one part of a broader treatment plan, rather than the entire solution. The temporary reduction in pain can be useful because it may make it […]